Freddy’s Custard Cookie Creatures

Share on FacebookTweet about this on TwitterFreddy's InstagramPin on PinterestEmail to someone

What could make eating a Freddy’s Custard Cookie Sandwich more magical? Eating one that looks like a unicorn, of course! These unicorn and monster desserts make the perfect treats for kids.

Scroll down for a step-by-step guide on how to make them. Be sure to pick up some Freddy’s Custard Cookie Sandwiches at your local Freddy’s.

Freddy’s Custard Cookie Sandwich Creatures

Freddy's Custard Cookie Sandwich Decorated


  • 6 Oreo® or Nutter Butter® Custard Sandwiches
  • 1 container of vanilla frosting
  • 1 unicorn cupcake decorating kit

Takes 30 min.,
serves 6.


  1. Scoop icing into a sandwich bag or piping bag.
  2. Pipe icing points around cookie surface.
  3. Use cupcake decorating kit to place eyes, ears and unicorn horn.
  4. Harden in freezer for 10 min before serving.

Freddy's Custard Cookie Sandwich Decorated